Surfin Betty’s Burger Bar has quickly become a local favorite in Bethany Beach, offering a neighborhood gathering spot where high-quality ingredients, nostalgia, and a relaxed atmosphere come together.

Born as an offshoot of the iconic Surfin’ Betty’s, which operated on the boardwalk from 1986 until 2019, this locally owned business carries forward the same love for community, fun, and exceptional food. 

With a menu focused on pasture-raised burgers, crispy chicken sandwiches, fresh-cut fries, and hand-spun milkshakes, the restaurant has become a destination for locals and visitors seeking good food and great memories.

This combination of local charm, dedication to quality, and a welcoming atmosphere makes Surfin Betty’s Burger Bar an ideal feature for the start of our Local Business Spotlight Series. 

Image Generated by AI

How Surfin Betty’s Got Its Start

Surfin Betty’s Burger Bar emerged from the legacy of its previous location on the boardwalk. 

After over three decades of serving beachgoers, the original bar closed in 2019, but the passion for great food and community didn’t stop there.

The team behind Surfin Betty’s wanted to create a neighborhood gathering spot in Bethany Beach, where friends and families could enjoy quality meals in a welcoming environment. 

The focus was on delivering the same nostalgic vibes of the original boardwalk bar while elevating the menu with pasture-raised beef, all-natural chicken, and fresh-cut sides.

Image Generated by AI

Pasture-Raised Beef and All-Natural Chicken

At the heart of Surfin Betty’s burgers is their partnership with Roseda Farms, a Maryland-based family-owned cattle farm. 

Roseda Farms emphasizes sustainability with solar-powered operations, gravity-based watering, and regenerative farming practices. 

All beef is pasture-raised, grass-fed, and dry-aged for 2 to 3 weeks, delivering a rich, steak-like flavor. 

Surfin Betty’s also takes care to offer high-quality poultry. All chicken is sourced from animals fed an all-vegetarian diet with no animal byproducts and no antibiotics, giving diners a healthy, flavorful option for sandwiches and meals.

Image Generated by AI

Surfin Betty’s Delicious Menu

The stand-out of Surfin Betty’s is, of course, its menu: A celebration of bold flavors, high-quality ingredients, and classic comfort food done exceptionally well. 

Some best burgers include:

• Betty Burger – The classic, with lettuce, tomato, onions, pickles, and Betty’s signature burger sauce.
• Jam Good Bacon! – Topped with homemade applewood bacon jam and caramelized onions for a burger that truly lives up to its name.
• Black and Bleu – Pickled red onions, lettuce, tomato, and Gorgonzola cheese for a bold, tangy twist.
• Bat Burger – Bacon, avocado, cheddar cheese, lettuce, and tomato for a hearty, flavorful option.

Image Generated by AI

Beyond burgers, Surfin Betty’s menu features an array of all-natural chicken options, from the crispy Krispy Chicken Caesar salad to the spicy Nashville Hot Chicken, coated in house-made breading, sriracha ranch, and pickles. 

Signature sandwiches like the Gen Z Chicken with bacon and ranch or the Shore Billy Chicken with Old Bay cheese showcase the creativity and flavor that make every bite memorable.

For those looking for lighter options, the Pipeline Salad, Baja Salad, and Caesar Salad can be customized with grilled chicken or a burger patty for an extra protein boost. 

Fries, nachos, and loaded baskets like the Gombbah Fries or Loaded Nachos round out the menu, making it easy to satisfy any craving.

And of course, no meal at Surfin Betty’s is complete without a hand-spun milkshake, smoothie, or ice cream float, the perfect sweet finish to a meal full of flavor. 

Pair it with a local craft beer, a refreshing cocktail, or a specialty soda, and you have a dining experience that’s as fun and vibrant as the beach community it serves.

Image Generated by AI

Surf’s Up: Continuing a Family Legacy

Surfin Betty’s is more than just a restaurant, it’s a continuation of a beloved local tradition. 

From the boardwalk roots of Surfin’ Betty’s Beach Bar to the bustling tables of Bethany Beach, the business remains rooted in community, family, and a shared love of great food.

As they serve pasture-raised burgers and hand-spun milkshakes, the team behind Surfin Betty’s invites guests to create memories that celebrate the spirit of the beach and the joy of a quality meal.

You can visit the restaurant at 786 Garfield Parkway, Bethany Beach. They’re open daily from 11am to 6pm Sunday to Wednesday and from 11am to 9pm Thursday to Saturday. 

Whether you’re craving a juicy, steak-flavored burger or a refreshing milkshake, every visit to Surfin Betty’s brings the best of Coastal Delaware to your plate. 

Don’t forget to keep following our blog for more stories highlighting the local businesses shaping this community!